The Dodgers are expected to sign the three-time Silver Slugger Award winner for $71 million.
The Los Angeles Dodgers are riding high after clinching their second World Series title in just five seasons, firmly cementing their position as one of baseball’s premier franchises. A critical factor in their success this past season was the stellar performance of outfielder Teoscar Hernández, whose contributions on and off the field played a pivotal role in propelling LA to the championship. However, as the offseason unfolds, the pressing question remains: will the Dodgers manage to retain the veteran slugger?
Last offseason, instead of locking into a multi-year agreement, Hernández chose to bet on his own abilities. He signed a one-year, $23.5 million deal with Los Angeles, a gamble that turned out to be incredibly lucrative. His stellar campaign earned him his second career All-Star selection, his first-ever championship ring, and his third Silver Slugger Award. Hernández’s 2023 season stats speak volumes: a .840 OPS, 33 home runs, 99 RBIs, and 84 runs scored across 652 plate appearances. These numbers underscore his immense value as a consistent offensive powerhouse.
Given his significant contributions to the Dodgers’ championship run, many around the league expected Hernández to swiftly re-sign with Los Angeles during this offseason. His return to the Dodgers was almost seen as a foregone conclusion, with fans and analysts alike anticipating a quick deal. Yet, as winter progresses, Hernández remains unsigned, leaving the door ajar for other teams to make a play for him. Two notable suitors reportedly interested in prying him away from LA are the Boston Red Sox and the New York Yankees, both of whom are eager to bolster their rosters with a proven, high-impact player.
Hernández’s impact on the Dodgers transcended his impressive on-field performance. He quickly became a key figure in the clubhouse, forging a strong bond with his teammates, including Shohei Ohtani. His vibrant personality and ability to energize the team—both through his bat and his infectious spirit—made him a fan favorite and a leader within the organization. Reflecting on Hernández’s contributions, Dodgers beat writer Rowan Kavner highlighted his importance: “Hernández played a major role in the Dodgers’ success last season and was a perfect fit both on the field, where he was an All-Star, and in the clubhouse, where he struck an immediate relationship with Ohtani and was a seed-throwing joy. [Manager Dave] Roberts said it would be tough to have to replace his presence in both regards.”
While Hernández’s decision to test free agency may raise questions about his long-term plans, it’s clear that the Dodgers have every incentive to keep him in Los Angeles. With their recent championship victory and a roster brimming with talent, the Dodgers are well-positioned to contend for another title next season. Retaining Hernández would ensure they maintain a potent lineup that has already proven its mettle against the league’s toughest competition.
For Hernández, the decision likely hinges on a combination of financial security, team culture, and competitive prospects. While Los Angeles can offer all three, the allure of potentially larger contracts or new opportunities with franchises like the Red Sox or Yankees could make things interesting. Both Boston and New York are in the market for an impactful outfielder, and Hernández’s track record makes him an ideal fit for their needs.
In Boston, Hernández would bring a much-needed jolt of power to a lineup looking to rebound after an underwhelming season. The Red Sox have made it clear that they intend to be aggressive this offseason, and adding a player of Hernández’s caliber would signal their commitment to returning to postseason contention. Meanwhile, the Yankees—always on the hunt for marquee players—could see Hernández as the perfect complement to their star-studded roster. Pairing him with Aaron Judge and other heavy hitters in their lineup would create a formidable offensive force capable of challenging any pitching staff in the league.
However, the Dodgers remain the most logical landing spot for Hernández. The team’s ability to consistently compete for championships, coupled with their supportive environment and deep pockets, makes them an ideal fit for a player looking to build on his legacy. For Los Angeles, losing Hernández would not only leave a significant void in their lineup but also disrupt the chemistry that helped drive their championship run.
From a strategic perspective, the Dodgers’ front office has historically excelled at identifying and retaining key players while maintaining roster flexibility. With Hernández, they face a critical decision. Offering a long-term deal with competitive terms would likely secure his services and send a strong message about their commitment to sustaining success. Yet, the financial implications of such a move could limit their ability to address other roster needs or pursue additional free agents.
As negotiations unfold, Hernández’s market value will likely be influenced by the broader dynamics of this year’s free agent pool. Players with similar skill sets and production levels will set benchmarks that agents and teams use during discussions. While Hernández’s offensive output and accolades make him a top-tier target, his defensive capabilities and age may also factor into the equation. At 31 years old, he’s in his prime, but teams may weigh the potential risks of a long-term deal as they evaluate their options.
The Dodgers’ approach to Hernández’s free agency could also be shaped by their recent history with similar situations. In past offseasons, they’ve shown a willingness to let notable players walk if the financial terms didn’t align with their long-term vision. However, they’ve also demonstrated a knack for retaining cornerstone talents when it aligns with their goals. How they navigate Hernández’s situation will provide insight into their strategy moving forward.
For now, Dodgers fans remain hopeful that Hernández will don the iconic blue and white uniform again next season. His electric bat, leadership qualities, and connection with the team’s core players make him an indispensable part of their formula for success. As one of the most exciting and impactful players in the league, Hernández has the opportunity to cement his legacy as a Dodger—if both sides can find common ground.
Ultimately, the resolution of Teoscar Hernández’s free agency saga will have significant implications not only for the Dodgers but also for the broader MLB landscape. Whether he stays in Los Angeles or opts for a new challenge, his decision will shape the competitive balance of the league in the years to come. For now, all eyes are on the Dodgers and Hernández as they navigate this crucial offseason.
