From an outsider’s perspective, the final three games of the 2024 NFL regular season could very well mark the end of Mike McCarthy’s tenure as head coach of the Dallas Cowboys. This sentiment is particularly strong among Cowboys fans, many of whom are eager for a change. However, the reality of McCarthy’s future may not be as clear-cut as it appears.
Behind the scenes, it seems that no definitive decision has been made regarding McCarthy’s position. Team owner Jerry Jones has yet to offer a firm commitment to McCarthy beyond this season. While Jones hasn’t explicitly endorsed him, he also hasn’t entirely ruled out the possibility of McCarthy continuing as head coach. The ambiguity leaves the door open, making it difficult to determine the organization’s plans for the head coaching role after the season concludes.
This uncertainty has fueled widespread speculation about what might come next. In just a few weeks, the Cowboys’ plans should become clearer, which could either solidify McCarthy’s role or initiate a search for a new head coach. With that in mind, we’ve compiled a list of potential candidates who we believe would be strong contenders to replace McCarthy. While these suggestions reflect our preferences rather than guaranteed outcomes, they highlight the type of leadership the Cowboys might pursue. Naturally, opinions on these choices will vary.
1. Aaron Glenn
Aaron Glenn is a familiar name to Cowboys fans, having played two seasons with the franchise during his 15-year NFL career. Since transitioning to coaching, Glenn has demonstrated significant growth, particularly as the defensive coordinator for the Detroit Lions. Under his leadership, the Lions transformed their defense from being ranked dead last in DVOA (Defense-adjusted Value Over Average) in 2020 to one of the league’s top-performing units in 2024. Glenn is highly regarded for his ability to inspire and lead players while maximizing their potential. His ties to the Cowboys and proven defensive acumen make him a compelling option for the head coach role.
2. Kliff Kingsbury
Kliff Kingsbury’s tenure as the head coach of the Arizona Cardinals may not have gone according to plan, but he has since revitalized his coaching reputation as the offensive coordinator for the Washington Commanders. Kingsbury has been instrumental in the development of rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels, helping him achieve early success in the NFL. Known for his innovative play-calling and offensive creativity, Kingsbury could inject fresh energy into the Cowboys’ offense. Rumors have already begun circulating that Kingsbury might be a leading candidate to replace McCarthy, and his track record makes him an intriguing possibility.
3. Mike Vrabel
If the Cowboys are serious about bringing in a no-nonsense leader with a proven track record, Mike Vrabel should be at the top of their list. Vrabel has established himself as one of the NFL’s most respected head coaches, combining discipline with a strong defensive mindset. His leadership style could address the Cowboys’ long-standing issues with penalties and lack of discipline. Additionally, Vrabel’s defensive expertise might help elevate the game of Micah Parsons, one of the team’s most dynamic players. Vrabel’s proven ability to build cohesive, competitive teams makes him an ideal candidate to take the Cowboys to the next level.
4. Joe Brady
As a potential Plan B for the Cowboys, Joe Brady offers plenty of upside. Brady first gained widespread attention for his role in helping Joe Burrow thrive during their time together at LSU, culminating in a national championship. Since transitioning to the NFL, Brady has continued to shine as the offensive coordinator for the Buffalo Bills. Under his guidance, the Bills have consistently ranked among the league’s top five teams in offensive DVOA during his three seasons with quarterback Josh Allen. Brady’s offensive vision and track record of developing quarterbacks could make him a great fit for working with Dak Prescott and the Cowboys’ offense.
5. Ben Johnson
Ben Johnson is expected to be one of the most sought-after candidates for head coaching positions this offseason. As the offensive coordinator for the Detroit Lions, Johnson has transformed their offense into one of the most efficient and creative units in the league. His innovative play-calling has not only revitalized the Lions’ offense but also helped resurrect the career of quarterback Jared Goff. Johnson’s ability to maximize the potential of high-profile players like Dak Prescott and CeeDee Lamb would be invaluable to the Cowboys. His offensive philosophy and knack for getting the best out of his players make him a top-tier candidate for the job.
