The Unexpected Return of Ed Orgeron to LSU

Ed Orgeron’s connection with LSU football is undeniably strong. As a former player, assistant coach, and the head coach who led LSU to a national championship in 2019, his place in the program’s history is secure. However, after being let go by LSU following the 2021 season due to a combination of on-field performance issues and off-field controversies, his return to Baton Rouge in 2025 would be surprising, yet not entirely out of the realm of possibility.

Let’s imagine how this scenario might unfold and what the implications could be for the program.

The Rise of Ed Orgeron at LSU

Orgeron was initially brought to LSU as the interim head coach in 2016 after the firing of Les Miles. He quickly won the favor of LSU fans with his brash, unapologetic style and deep understanding of the program’s culture. His Louisiana roots gave him an authentic connection to the state and its people, something that resonated deeply with the fanbase. However, it wasn’t until 2019 that Orgeron truly solidified his place in LSU lore.

In 2019, Orgeron and his coaching staff, most notably offensive coordinator Joe Brady and quarterback Joe Burrow, orchestrated one of the greatest seasons in college football history. The Tigers finished the regular season 12-0, capped off by a dominant SEC Championship game win over Georgia, before eventually defeating Clemson in the National Championship game. Orgeron’s fiery leadership and the cohesion of the LSU team brought the university its fourth national title in football, a feat that seemed improbable at the beginning of the season.

The 2019 LSU Tigers were more than just a talented team; they represented a perfect storm of elite talent, innovative coaching, and a sense of destiny that made them one of the most unstoppable forces in college football history. Under Orgeron’s leadership, LSU was the envy of college football, and Orgeron’s infectious energy made him an iconic figure in the sport.

The Decline: What Led to His Exit?

However, the joy from the 2019 season was short-lived. While Orgeron’s championship victory brought glory to LSU, the years following it were less successful. The Tigers struggled through the 2020 and 2021 seasons, marred by inconsistent play, locker room issues, and a general lack of direction. Despite Orgeron’s status as a fan favorite and the respect he had garnered for his championship run, the decline on the field was evident, leading to his dismissal after the 2021 season.

Several factors contributed to Orgeron’s departure:

1. Roster Turnover: The departure of key players like Joe Burrow, Justin Jefferson, and other stars from the 2019 season created a talent void. LSU struggled to replace the stars of the championship squad, and this impacted their on-field performance.
2. Recruiting Struggles: While LSU remained competitive in recruiting, there were signs that Orgeron’s recruiting efforts were not as sharp as they had been in 2019. The inconsistency in talent acquisition became a concern for LSU’s long-term success.
3. Off-the-Field Controversies: Orgeron’s tenure was also impacted by off-the-field issues, including legal and personal controversies, which drew negative attention to the program.
4. Inability to Adapt: Orgeron’s traditional approach to football, grounded in a strong defense and a conservative offensive system, was seen as outdated, especially in an era where offenses like Alabama and Clemson were thriving through innovation and high-powered attacks.

Though Orgeron’s exit was ultimately the right move for LSU at the time, his abrupt departure left fans conflicted. Many appreciated the success he had brought to LSU, while others were disappointed by the way things ended.

The Hypothetical Return in 2025

If Orgeron were to return as LSU’s head coach in 2025, it would be a remarkable twist in the narrative of LSU football. Given the rise of new coaches and the expectations that come with a program of LSU’s stature, such a move would raise many questions and spark debates among fans, media, and alumni.

What would prompt a return? Here are a few possible factors:

1. Stabilization of LSU’s Program: After the tumultuous years post-Orgeron, LSU may seek a familiar face to help stabilize the program. The university may decide that Orgeron’s experience with the Tigers, along with his roots in Louisiana, would make him an ideal candidate to restore LSU to its winning ways.
2. Recruiting Renaissance: With Orgeron’s deep ties to Louisiana, it is possible that he could reconnect with the state’s elite recruits, reigniting the recruiting pipeline that helped propel LSU to success in the past. The potential to land top-tier Louisiana talent could be a significant factor in his return.
3. A Different Coaching Approach: Having had time to reflect on his tenure and the challenges he faced, Orgeron may return with a more refined coaching philosophy, perhaps one that incorporates more modern offensive strategies and leadership techniques. If he were to bring in fresh assistants with new ideas, Orgeron might adapt in a way that fans and alumni find exciting.
4. The LSU Football Community’s Desire for a Change: A desire for change or a fresh direction might create an opening for Orgeron to step back in. If the program struggles to find success under a new head coach, the LSU administration might consider Orgeron as a seasoned and passionate leader who can reignite the team’s competitive fire.

What Would His Return Mean for LSU Football?

If Ed Orgeron were to return to LSU as head coach, there would be a mix of emotions in Baton Rouge. Some fans would be thrilled to see him back in charge, while others might feel that the program should move forward with fresh leadership. Here’s how Orgeron’s return might affect different aspects of LSU football:

1. The Fanbase: Orgeron’s return would undoubtedly elicit a strong emotional response from LSU fans. Many would embrace the nostalgia of the 2019 championship and the passionate coach who made LSU feel like a family. However, others may worry about his ability to adapt to the current landscape of college football, especially given the changes in recruiting and offensive strategies since his departure.
2. The Team: Orgeron is known for his fiery leadership and ability to connect with players on a personal level. His return could energize the LSU locker room and motivate players to perform at their highest levels. However, there would also be questions about whether his methods and philosophies could work in the current college football climate, where offensive innovation and dynamic quarterbacks are at the forefront.
3. Recruiting: As mentioned, Orgeron’s ties to Louisiana are a significant advantage. His return would likely help LSU reassert itself as a dominant force in state recruiting. The state of Louisiana consistently produces elite talent, and Orgeron’s familiarity with local high schools and coaches could help LSU regain control of its home turf.
4. The National Perception: College football is an ever-changing landscape, and Orgeron’s return could signal that LSU is committed to getting back to the top of the SEC. However, there might also be skepticism from critics who believe that the program needs a new, innovative voice to navigate the modern challenges of college football.
5. The LSU Athletic Department: For the LSU administration, the decision to bring Orgeron back would come with a certain amount of risk. Would he be able to duplicate the success of 2019, or would his tenure suffer from the same issues that led to his departure? The administration would likely weigh the potential for a return to glory against the possible challenges of maintaining consistency and navigating external pressures.