A Quarterback Away (Obviously): Miami’s Offense Needs to Replace Output in 2025, but There is Still Room for Improvement

The Miami Dolphins had a thrilling season in 2024, showing flashes of offensive brilliance, but ultimately fell short in the postseason. While much of the talk around the Dolphins in the last few years has centered around their defense and coaching decisions, it is undeniable that their offensive success is the team’s biggest key to competing for a championship in 2025.

One of the most glaring issues the Dolphins faced in 2024, and will continue to wrestle with in 2025, is their quarterback situation. Miami has talent at many positions, but they have yet to solidify the most important one: quarterback. With the team being just “a quarterback away” from potentially making a deeper playoff run, there is no doubt that the Dolphins need to address the position this offseason. However, while quarterback is the obvious focus, Miami’s offensive line, receiving corps, and running back group each offer avenues for improvement, which will contribute to a more potent offensive attack in the coming year.

Quarterback Conundrum: A Work in Progress

The Miami Dolphins’ quarterback situation in 2024 was characterized by inconsistency, injury concerns, and missed opportunities. Tua Tagovailoa, while showing flashes of elite-level play, was often hindered by injuries that kept him out of action for several weeks. His absence exposed the lack of depth at the quarterback position, with the Dolphins relying on backups who failed to provide the necessary stability and playmaking ability. As Miami enters 2025, the front office must make a decision regarding Tua’s future.

Tua’s performance when healthy showed promise. His precision as a passer and ability to lead Miami’s high-octane offense is something that cannot be dismissed. However, the reality is that Tua has shown a propensity for injuries, especially concussions, and while he is a gifted quarterback, his health remains a major concern. If the Dolphins choose to stick with him, they must build a better infrastructure around him — namely, a more resilient offensive line and additional depth at quarterback.

For Miami to reach their full potential, the team may need to consider adding a more reliable option to the quarterback room. A proven veteran or a highly-touted rookie could provide the stability needed to elevate Miami’s offense. A healthy quarterback who can stay on the field for an entire season is critical for the team’s Super Bowl aspirations. Regardless of whether Tua stays or another player is brought in, it’s clear that finding a durable, consistent playmaker under center is essential for Miami in 2025.

Offensive Line: A Work in Progress

One of the most important but often overlooked aspects of Miami’s offense in 2024 was their offensive line. The line’s performance was a mixed bag: at times, it provided enough time for the quarterbacks to operate, but on other occasions, it crumbled under pressure. This inconsistency affected both the passing and rushing attacks. The line gave up too many sacks, which put unnecessary pressure on the quarterbacks, and it struggled to open holes for the running backs.

Moving forward, the Dolphins must address their offensive line issues. Their ability to protect the quarterback and create space in the running game will be crucial to Miami’s success in 2025. Some players, like tackle Austin Jackson, showed flashes of improvement but need to build more consistency, while other positions are more uncertain.

In the upcoming offseason, Miami must prioritize the offensive line in free agency and the draft. This may involve signing proven tackles or guards who can provide immediate impact, as well as developing young players to create depth. The team should also focus on improving the chemistry and communication across the offensive line, which often struggles with pass protection in high-pressure situations. The addition of a new coach to help with offensive line development or a scheme tweak could go a long way in improving Miami’s overall offensive output.

The Playmakers: Speed and Explosiveness

Miami’s receiving corps has one of the most exciting groups of playmakers in the NFL. Wide receivers Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle offer two of the fastest and most dynamic threats in the league. Hill, in particular, has been a difference-maker for the Dolphins, turning seemingly ordinary plays into extraordinary ones. Waddle’s deep speed and ability to stretch the field is the perfect complement to Hill, making Miami one of the most dangerous passing attacks in the NFL when the offense is firing on all cylinders.

However, while the duo of Hill and Waddle is excellent, the Dolphins could benefit from bolstering their receiving corps to add another dimension. Miami’s depth behind Hill and Waddle is thin, which limits the team’s ability to stretch the field consistently and create mismatches on every play. A reliable third option would make the offense even more difficult to defend, especially as defensive coordinators adjust to Hill and Waddle.

In 2025, Miami must focus on adding another top-tier receiver. This could be through the draft, where there are several standout wideouts available, or through free agency. The Dolphins may also need to get creative in utilizing their existing players and positioning them in unique ways to force opposing defenses to account for all their weapons. A true “X” receiver who can be a reliable target in the middle of the field would give Miami the ability to attack all areas of the field with more consistency.

The addition of a reliable tight end could also help Miami’s offensive output. Tight ends have become an increasingly important position in the NFL, and the Dolphins are currently lacking a dynamic presence at the position. A player who can create mismatches in the passing game and provide an additional option for the quarterback would make a big difference in how the offense operates in 2025.

Running Back Situation: A Better Balance

Miami’s rushing attack in 2024 was a bit underwhelming, given the offensive talent the team had in other areas. While Raheem Mostert showed flashes of brilliance, the running game as a whole struggled to gain consistent yardage and balance out the offense. The Dolphins’ reliance on a pass-heavy scheme often left the running backs without much opportunity to establish a rhythm.

Moving into 2025, the Dolphins will need to focus on establishing a more balanced offensive approach, with an emphasis on the running game. To do so, the team may look to improve their running back depth. While Mostert has been effective when healthy, he’s no longer a young player, and durability concerns make it important for Miami to bring in another capable ball-carrier. The team could target a power back who can wear down defenses and create short-yardage success, especially in critical situations like third-and-short.

Additionally, Miami’s offensive line must improve its run-blocking capabilities to facilitate a more effective ground game. If the Dolphins can establish a more consistent rushing attack, they will be able to take pressure off their quarterback and keep defenses honest, making the passing game even more dangerous. A solid ground game also helps control the clock, which could be crucial for Miami in tight games during the postseason.

The Coaching Staff: Building Upon Success

While Miami’s offense has had its struggles, it’s important to acknowledge the work done by head coach Mike McDaniel. McDaniel’s offensive system, based on a blend of Shanahan-style zone runs and creative passing concepts, has been instrumental in unlocking the potential of players like Hill, Waddle, and Tua. His ability to adjust the game plan based on the opponent is a positive aspect of his coaching, but there are areas where McDaniel can continue to grow.

In 2025, the Dolphins should focus on improving the offensive scheme to become even more dynamic. This could mean further developing the ground game to complement the passing attack, as well as finding ways to integrate new playmakers into the system. The team could also benefit from refining their red zone offense, as finishing drives with touchdowns instead of field goals was an area of concern in 2024.

Additionally, Miami must continue to invest in their coaching staff to ensure there is continuity and a steady progression of offensive development. If McDaniel can refine his system and eliminate some of the inconsistencies that have plagued the offense, Miami’s attack will be much more potent in 2025.