Mike McCarthy Could Be Replaced by These Six Dallas Cowboys Head Coach Candidates
The Dallas Cowboys, one of the NFL’s most storied and high-profile franchises, have consistently been a team under the microscope. With immense talent on the roster and a passionate fanbase, expectations are always high for success in Dallas. Mike McCarthy, the current head coach, has faced mixed reviews since taking over in 2020. While he led the Cowboys to the playoffs in two of his first three seasons, his leadership has often been questioned, especially after a disappointing loss to the San Francisco 49ers in the 2023 playoffs.
Given the high standard of success that the Cowboys franchise demands, McCarthy’s future has been a subject of speculation. Many fans and analysts believe that the Cowboys could be in search of a new head coach sooner rather than later, especially if they do not meet expectations in the upcoming season. The team’s roster is teeming with talent, including quarterback Dak Prescott, running back Tony Pollard, wide receiver CeeDee Lamb, and an elite defense led by Micah Parsons, so the right head coach could elevate this squad to Super Bowl contention.
In this article, we will explore six potential candidates who could be the next head coach of the Dallas Cowboys, analyzing their backgrounds, coaching philosophies, and what they could bring to the franchise.
1. Sean Payton (Former New Orleans Saints Head Coach)
Background:
Sean Payton is widely considered one of the top offensive minds in the NFL. Having spent 15 years as the head coach of the New Orleans Saints, Payton built one of the most potent offenses in league history, led by Hall of Fame quarterback Drew Brees. During his tenure, Payton helped the Saints capture a Super Bowl championship in 2009 and consistently fielded competitive teams year after year. He stepped down from his position in 2022, leading to speculation that he could be interested in another head coaching gig.
Why He Fits the Cowboys:
Payton is exactly the type of experienced coach who could take the Dallas Cowboys to the next level. His offensive acumen would immediately improve the team’s inconsistent offense, and he has a proven track record of success in big games. In particular, Payton’s ability to build an efficient and explosive offense around a quarterback, coupled with his high football IQ, makes him an attractive candidate for a team that needs to get the most out of Dak Prescott. Payton is also known for his discipline and leadership, qualities that could help elevate the Cowboys to elite status.
Potential Impact:
Payton’s ability to adapt his offensive system to different personnel would be crucial for the Cowboys. With Dak Prescott at quarterback and an elite skill-position group, Payton could develop a high-powered offense that makes the most of the team’s weapons. Payton is also known for his creative game plans, which would help Dallas’s offense keep defenses off balance. Additionally, his leadership and experience in managing high-pressure situations could prove valuable in guiding the Cowboys to the playoffs and beyond.
2. Dan Quinn (Dallas Cowboys Defensive Coordinator)
Background:
Dan Quinn has established himself as one of the most respected defensive minds in the NFL. He has spent time as the defensive coordinator for several teams, including the Seattle Seahawks, where he helped orchestrate one of the most dominant defenses in recent memory. Quinn was the head coach of the Atlanta Falcons from 2015 to 2020, where he led the team to a Super Bowl appearance in 2017. Since joining the Cowboys as their defensive coordinator in 2021, Quinn has transformed the Dallas defense into one of the league’s best, with stars like Micah Parsons, Trevon Diggs, and DeMarcus Lawrence leading the way.
Why He Fits the Cowboys:
Quinn’s success as a defensive coordinator with the Cowboys has led to calls for him to be considered for the head coaching job. He has a deep understanding of the NFL and an ability to craft game plans that maximize the talents of his players. Quinn’s defensive prowess could be a major asset to a team that already has a top-tier defense. While he has not had a head coaching position since his time in Atlanta, his time in Dallas as defensive coordinator has revitalized his career and given him a platform to prove that he is ready for another head coaching opportunity.
Potential Impact:
Quinn could bring stability and consistency to the Cowboys’ defense while also being a strong presence in the locker room. With a proven track record in leading defenses, he could ensure that the Cowboys continue to be a defensive powerhouse. On the offensive side of the ball, Quinn would likely lean on his offensive staff to develop a more balanced attack. His ability to build a cohesive team and get the most out of his players would help elevate the Cowboys, especially on defense. However, his lack of recent experience as a head coach could present some challenges in terms of managing the overall team dynamic.
3. Kellen Moore (Former Dallas Cowboys Offensive Coordinator)
Background:
Kellen Moore served as the Cowboys’ offensive coordinator from 2019 to 2022, and during that time, he was responsible for overseeing the development of Dak Prescott and the team’s offensive scheme. Moore, who had a brief playing career as a quarterback in the NFL, is regarded as a young and innovative mind in the world of coaching. Under his guidance, the Cowboys’ offense ranked among the top in the league in terms of yards and points scored in several seasons.
Moore left the Cowboys after the 2022 season and became the offensive coordinator for the Los Angeles Chargers. However, given his familiarity with the Cowboys’ roster and his success as the team’s offensive coordinator, Moore is often mentioned as a potential candidate for the head coaching role.
Why He Fits the Cowboys:
Moore’s familiarity with the Cowboys’ personnel and offense makes him a logical candidate. He knows the strengths and weaknesses of the roster, particularly the offense, and could develop a system that maximizes Dak Prescott’s talents. Moore has demonstrated that he can run an efficient and high-scoring offense, and given the Cowboys’ offensive talent, he could quickly turn the unit into one of the league’s most potent. Moreover, Moore is a young and innovative coach who would likely bring fresh ideas to the team and create a more modern offensive approach.
Potential Impact:
If Moore were hired as the head coach, the transition would be relatively seamless given his previous experience with the team. He could continue to work with Prescott and the offensive playmakers, making sure the Cowboys’ offense remains one of the best in the league. Moore’s ability to tailor his offensive system to his players would be an asset in helping Dak Prescott reach his full potential. However, Moore’s lack of head coaching experience might make some question whether he has the leadership qualities required to handle the overall responsibilities of a head coach.
4. Jim Harbaugh (University of Michigan Head Coach)
Background:
Jim Harbaugh, currently the head coach of the University of Michigan football team, has a long and successful coaching career at both the collegiate and NFL levels. As head coach of the San Francisco 49ers from 2011 to 2014, Harbaugh revitalized the franchise and led them to the Super Bowl in 2012. Known for his fiery personality, strong leadership skills, and innovative coaching style, Harbaugh is widely regarded as one of the best coaches in the game.
After spending several successful years in the NFL, Harbaugh moved to Michigan in 2015, where he has continued to build a powerhouse program. Despite his success in college football, rumors have swirled that Harbaugh may be interested in a return to the NFL, particularly if the right opportunity arises.
Why He Fits the Cowboys:
Harbaugh is known for his ability to build a winning culture, and the Cowboys are in need of a coach who can bring stability and leadership to a team that has often underperformed in the postseason. His ability to manage large personalities and create a culture of discipline and toughness would be beneficial in Dallas, where expectations are sky-high. Harbaugh’s experience in the NFL would give him a strong foundation to work with, and he would be able to build a team that is both mentally tough and disciplined.
Potential Impact:
Harbaugh’s fiery personality and leadership would be a stark contrast to McCarthy’s more laid-back style. His intensity and passion could help light a fire under the Cowboys’ players, particularly Dak Prescott, who has been inconsistent at times. Harbaugh’s ability to create a strong team culture could help the Cowboys become more resilient and focused when the stakes are high. However, some may question whether Harbaugh’s brash personality would mesh with Jerry Jones and the Cowboys’ front office.
5. Matt Eberflus (Chicago Bears Head Coach)
Background:
Matt Eberflus is currently the head coach of the Chicago Bears, having been hired in 2022. Prior to that, Eberflus was the defensive coordinator for the Indianapolis Colts, where he earned a reputation as a strong defensive mind. Eberflus helped lead the Colts to several successful seasons on the defensive side of the ball. While his tenure with the Bears has had its ups and downs, he has continued to build a foundation for success in Chicago.
Why He Fits the Cowboys:
Eberflus is a rising star in the NFL coaching ranks and could be a potential candidate for the Cowboys if they are looking for a fresh approach. His strong defensive background would align well with the Cowboys’ already elite defense. Eberflus is known for his focus on discipline and attention to detail, which could help the Cowboys become more consistent in all phases of the game. His experience working with young players, such as in Chicago, could also be an asset in helping the Cowboys’ younger talents develop into stars.
Potential Impact:
Eberflus could bring a more structured and disciplined approach to the Cowboys, particularly on the defensive side of the ball. His experience as a defensive coordinator would ensure that the Cowboys’ defense remains one of the top units in the league. Offensively, he would likely rely on his staff to develop a system that maximizes the potential of Dak Prescott and the Cowboys’ skill players. While his lack of experience as a head coach might be a concern, his defensive acumen and ability to build a strong team culture could be valuable assets for the Cowboys.
6. DeMeco Ryans (San Francisco 49ers Head Coach)
Background:
DeMeco Ryans is one of the most promising young head coaches in the NFL today. After a successful career as a linebacker with the Houston Texans and Philadelphia Eagles, Ryans transitioned into coaching and quickly became one of the brightest defensive minds in the league. As the defensive coordinator for the San Francisco 49ers, Ryans developed one of the league’s most dominant defenses, helping to lead the 49ers to consistent playoff appearances. His coaching acumen and leadership have made him a sought-after candidate for head coaching jobs.
Why He Fits the Cowboys:
Ryans’ defensive background would pair perfectly with the Cowboys’ already-talented defense. His ability to motivate and develop players would be key in continuing to make Dallas one of the top defensive teams in the NFL. Furthermore, his leadership and coaching presence would provide the Cowboys with a fresh direction, particularly in terms of creating a culture of accountability. Ryans is known for his intelligence and ability to adapt his defensive schemes to shut down opposing offenses, a trait that would be valuable for the Cowboys.
Potential Impact:
Ryans could continue to build upon the Cowboys’ defensive success and transform them into a top contender. He is also known for his calm demeanor, which contrasts with some of the other fiery personalities in coaching, and his ability to connect with players. Offensively, Ryans would likely need to rely on a strong offensive coordinator to help Dak Prescott and the offensive skill players thrive. Nonetheless, Ryans’ leadership and tactical brilliance could be exactly what the Cowboys need to become a Super Bowl contender.
