Giants Make Bold Trade for Quarterback in New Mock Draft Trade Proposal
As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, all eyes are on the New York Giants and their future plans at the most crucial position in football: quarterback. While the Giants have Daniel Jones on the roster, his performance over the past few seasons has raised questions about whether he is the long-term solution for the franchise. With the 2025 NFL Draft offering several high-quality quarterback prospects, the Giants could be one of the most active teams in terms of trade talks and movement.
In a new mock draft trade proposal that has sent shockwaves through the league, the Giants make a bold move to secure a quarterback of the future. This trade would see New York jump up in the draft to secure one of the top signal-callers, ensuring that they can compete at the highest level for years to come. With multiple teams vying for top draft picks, the Giants would need to make a substantial trade to secure the quarterback they want, and the bold move could have a lasting impact on the team’s future trajectory.
In this article, we will dive into the details of this mock trade proposal, analyzing the potential implications for the Giants and how this trade could reshape the future of the franchise. Additionally, we will look at which quarterback the Giants might target in this proposed trade, the current state of the Giants’ roster, and the broader context of the 2025 NFL Draft.
The Case for a Quarterback Trade
The New York Giants find themselves at a crossroads with Daniel Jones. After being drafted with the sixth overall pick in the 2019 NFL Draft, Jones showed promise in his early years but has failed to live up to the high expectations set for him. Despite some flashes of brilliance, including leading the Giants to the playoffs in 2023, Jones’ overall inconsistency has raised doubts about whether he can be the long-term answer at quarterback for New York.
In 2024, Jones’ performance continued to fluctuate, with high highs and low lows. While his mobility and ability to extend plays have been valuable assets, his decision-making and struggles with turnovers have been concerning. As a result, the Giants may be looking to make a bold move to secure a new quarterback and begin a new chapter for the franchise.
With the 2025 NFL Draft featuring several highly talented quarterback prospects, including Drake Maye from North Carolina, Caleb Williams from USC, and Quinn Ewers from Texas, the Giants could see this as the perfect opportunity to draft their quarterback of the future. A strong class of quarterbacks, combined with New York’s position in the draft, could make this an ideal year for the Giants to make a move.
The Trade Proposal: Moving Up for a Quarterback
In the mock draft trade proposal, the New York Giants make a bold trade to move up from their current draft position, which is in the middle of the first round, to secure one of the top quarterbacks in the 2025 class. This trade would involve the Giants sending multiple draft picks, including next year’s first-round pick, to a team currently holding one of the top picks in the draft.
The team the Giants are reportedly targeting for a trade is the Indianapolis Colts, who are currently holding the 4th overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft. The Colts, with Anthony Richardson already in place as their quarterback, are in a unique position to move down in the draft and acquire additional picks for future use. This sets the stage for a potential deal between New York and Indianapolis, with the Giants jumping ahead of several teams in need of a quarterback to secure their next franchise signal-caller.
In this trade, the Giants would likely send their 2025 first-round pick, a 2026 second-round pick, and a third-rounder to the Colts, allowing Indianapolis to bolster their roster with future picks while giving the Giants the opportunity to select their quarterback of the future. The Giants’ move would send a clear message to their fanbase and the league that they are committed to rebuilding around a new face at the position.
Which Quarterback Do the Giants Target?
Now that the Giants are in position to draft a quarterback in the top five, the question becomes: which quarterback will they target in this trade? There are several strong options available, and each has its own unique strengths and potential fit within the Giants’ offense. Here, we will break down three of the top quarterback prospects in the 2025 NFL Draft and analyze why the Giants might target each one.
1. Caleb Williams (USC)
Caleb Williams is widely considered the top quarterback prospect in the 2025 NFL Draft, and for good reason. The USC signal-caller has been nothing short of spectacular in his college career, winning the 2024 Heisman Trophy and leading the Trojans to an impressive season. Williams has everything a team could want in a quarterback—elite arm strength, accuracy, mobility, and football intelligence.
Williams has displayed the ability to make every throw in the book, and his natural playmaking ability has been on full display in big moments. He’s also known for his leadership and ability to elevate the play of those around him. For the Giants, Williams would represent a dynamic option at quarterback, giving them a dual-threat signal-caller who can create plays with his legs when necessary while maintaining the ability to make pinpoint throws downfield.
If the Giants are able to land Williams through this trade, it would immediately upgrade their offense and give them a face of the franchise who could be a fixture in New York for the next decade. His combination of talent and leadership would make him a perfect fit for the Giants’ rebuilding efforts.
2. Drake Maye (North Carolina)
Another top quarterback option for the Giants is Drake Maye from North Carolina. Maye has been a highly touted prospect throughout his college career, displaying tremendous poise, accuracy, and a deep understanding of the game. He is known for his ability to read defenses and make quick decisions, traits that would translate well to the pro game.
Maye is often compared to some of the top quarterbacks in recent drafts due to his accuracy and ball placement. He has shown the ability to thrive in both the pocket and on the move, making him an intriguing option for a team like the Giants. His skill set would mesh well with New York’s offensive system, and his leadership qualities could help him develop into a franchise quarterback.
While Williams may be the more dynamic athlete, Maye’s high floor and ability to perform consistently in all aspects of the game make him an appealing option for the Giants. If the Giants want a polished and reliable quarterback, Maye could be their guy.
3. Quinn Ewers (Texas)
Finally, Quinn Ewers from Texas is another quarterback the Giants could target with their trade. Ewers, who has developed into one of the most exciting young quarterbacks in college football, has the prototypical size (6’3″, 215 lbs) and arm strength that NFL teams covet. He is capable of making all the throws and has shown flashes of brilliance, especially in big games.
Ewers has also demonstrated impressive poise under pressure, and his ability to throw with velocity and accuracy makes him a tantalizing prospect. His experience playing in a high-pressure program like Texas will prepare him for the rigors of the NFL, and his upside as a future NFL starter is significant.
For the Giants, Ewers could represent a quarterback with significant upside, particularly as he continues to refine his game. He’s shown growth over his college career, and with the right coaching, he could develop into a dynamic playmaker for the Giants.
The Giants’ Roster and Future Outlook
While the decision to move up for a quarterback is the biggest story for the Giants, the team’s overall roster and future outlook are also factors that must be considered. New York has a solid foundation in place with a strong defense, featuring players like Dexter Lawrence, Kayvon Thibodeaux, and Adoree’ Jackson. The team’s offensive line has also shown improvement, and the Giants’ receiving corps, led by Darius Slayton and Isaiah Hodgins, provides some solid options.
However, the biggest hole on the roster remains the quarterback position. With Jones’ future uncertain, the Giants must act quickly to secure a quarterback who can lead them into the future. The team’s strong defensive core and promising offensive weapons make them an attractive destination for a young quarterback, and the addition of a top-tier signal-caller could be the missing piece to the Giants’ playoff aspirations.
In the short term, the Giants would likely need to bring in a veteran quarterback to help mentor their rookie signal-caller. This could be a transitional year for New York, with the rookie quarterback taking over the reins once he is fully prepared.
Conclusion: A Bold Move for the Future
The Giants’ potential trade for a top quarterback in the 2025 NFL Draft is a bold and necessary move for the franchise. With several talented quarterbacks available, New York has the opportunity to secure the future of their offense for years to come. Whether they target Caleb Williams, Drake Maye, or Quinn Ewers, the Giants are setting themselves up for success by addressing the most important position on the field.
This move is a statement that the Giants are committed to building a contender, and the acquisition of a young quarterback could have a ripple effect on the entire roster. With a strong defense and promising offensive pieces, the addition of a future superstar quarterback could put the Giants in the conversation for playoff contention in the near future.
By making this bold trade, the Giants are signaling their intent to be competitive for the long haul. With the right quarterback in place, New York’s future looks bright, and the next era of Giants football could be one of sustained success.
