In the lead-up to the 2024 Major League Baseball season, the Los Angeles Dodgers faced a unique challenge: integrating three MVP-caliber players—Mookie Betts, Freddie Freeman, and Shohei Ohtani—into their batting lineup. Manager Dave Roberts sought to optimize the team’s offensive potential by determining the most effective batting order for this trio.
Mookie Betts’ Preference
Mookie Betts, a seasoned leadoff hitter, expressed a clear preference for batting first or second in the lineup. This inclination stemmed from his extensive experience and success in the leadoff position, where he had previously excelled. Betts’ comfort and historical performance in this spot made him a strong candidate for the leadoff role.
Shohei Ohtani’s Flexibility
In contrast, Shohei Ohtani, the two-way superstar, demonstrated a flexible approach to his batting position. Ohtani conveyed that he was indifferent to where he batted in the lineup, prioritizing the team’s overall success over personal preference. This adaptability allowed Roberts to consider various lineup configurations without concern for Ohtani’s comfort.
Freddie Freeman’s Stance
Freddie Freeman, another former MVP, expressed a preference against batting leadoff. His experience and success in the middle of the lineup made him more comfortable in those positions, where he could focus on driving in runs and capitalizing on opportunities created by the top of the order.
Roberts’ Decision-Making Process
Faced with these preferences, Roberts convened a meeting with Betts, Freeman, and Ohtani to discuss the batting order. During this discussion, Betts advocated for the leadoff spot, Ohtani remained flexible, and Freeman preferred a middle-of-the-order position. Roberts acknowledged the importance of aligning the lineup with the players’ preferences to maintain morale and performance.
Betts in the Leadoff Spot
Ultimately, Betts began the 2024 season as the leadoff hitter, a position where he had previously thrived. His familiarity with this role allowed him to set the tone for the offense, utilizing his speed and on-base skills to create scoring opportunities.
Ohtani’s Role
Shohei Ohtani, with his exceptional hitting prowess, was positioned in the two-hole, capitalizing on Betts’ ability to get on base. This arrangement allowed Ohtani to drive in runs early in the game, taking advantage of the momentum established by the leadoff hitter.
Freeman’s Position
Freddie Freeman, preferring a middle-of-the-order spot, was placed in the three or four position, depending on the matchup. This placement allowed him to focus on driving in runs and providing protection for Ohtani, creating a formidable middle of the lineup.
Mid-Season Adjustments
During the season, Betts suffered a fractured left hand, which sidelined him for approximately two months. During his absence, Ohtani was moved to the leadoff position, where he continued to excel. Upon Betts’ return, Roberts chose to keep Ohtani in the leadoff spot due to his success there, while Betts resumed his role in the two-hole. This adjustment demonstrated Roberts’ willingness to adapt the lineup based on player performance and team needs.
Impact on Team Performance
The strategic placement of Betts, Ohtani, and Freeman in the lineup contributed to the Dodgers’ offensive success throughout the 2024 season. Betts’ speed and on-base skills at the top of the order, combined with Ohtani’s power and Freeman’s consistency, created a dynamic and potent lineup that kept opposing pitchers on their toes.
