The Joel Klatt Show regularly delves into the intricacies of college football, exploring both the historical context and the future potential of programs like Ohio State and Notre Dame. A topic that frequently arises in discussions surrounding college football’s national championship race is which of these two prestigious programs will emerge as the victor in the ever-competitive landscape of college football. Both Ohio State and Notre Dame have illustrious histories, passionate fanbases, and a legacy of success that positions them as perennial contenders. In this piece, we will analyze each program’s strengths and weaknesses in 2025, explore key factors that could influence the national championship race, and predict who will take home the coveted trophy.
Overview of Ohio State and Notre Dame’s Recent Successes
Ohio State has long been one of the most dominant programs in college football. Since the hiring of head coach Ryan Day in 2019, the Buckeyes have remained a powerhouse in the Big Ten Conference and on the national stage. Ohio State has consistently appeared in the College Football Playoff (CFP), a testament to the program’s sustained excellence in recruiting, coaching, and player development. The Buckeyes are known for their high-powered offense, led by elite quarterbacks, explosive running backs, and game-breaking wide receivers. Additionally, Ohio State’s defense, while sometimes inconsistent in recent years, has the potential to dominate when it performs at its best.
In contrast, Notre Dame, under head coach Marcus Freeman, has been on an upward trajectory since he took over in 2022. While the Fighting Irish have not yet won a national championship in the CFP era, they have consistently been competitive in the major bowl games and have appeared in the playoff picture on multiple occasions. Freeman’s leadership has revitalized the program, and Notre Dame is known for its strong defense, balanced offense, and disciplined approach to the game. The program also benefits from its independent status, which allows it more flexibility in scheduling and building a national brand.
1. Offense: Ohio State’s Explosive Attack vs. Notre Dame’s Balanced Approach
Ohio State’s offense in 2025 is poised to be one of the most potent in the nation. The Buckeyes have consistently recruited at an elite level, which has allowed them to assemble a roster full of dynamic playmakers. Quarterback development has been a hallmark of the program, with players like Justin Fields, Dwayne Haskins, and C.J. Stroud having starred in recent years. In 2025, Ohio State will likely feature another top-tier quarterback with the potential to lead the offense to greatness. This quarterback will be supported by an elite group of wide receivers, many of whom are future NFL talents.
The Ohio State passing game is often one of the most difficult to defend in college football due to the speed and athleticism of its wideouts. Whether it’s a deep ball to a speedy wide receiver or a short pass to a dynamic playmaker in space, the Buckeyes’ offense is designed to create mismatches and exploit defenses. In 2025, look for Ohio State to continue to lean on its aerial attack, utilizing quick-strike plays and tempo to keep opposing defenses off balance.
On the other hand, Notre Dame’s offense in 2025 will likely be more methodical and balanced, with an emphasis on running the football and controlling the tempo of the game. Notre Dame’s offense has historically been built around a strong offensive line and a powerful running game. In recent years, the Fighting Irish have been able to develop a stable of talented running backs who can take over games. In 2025, this ground game will likely be complemented by a more dynamic passing attack under the direction of quarterback Sam Hartman, who transferred from Wake Forest to Notre Dame and provided a much-needed boost in 2024.
Hartman’s experience and ability to make all the necessary throws should help balance the offense and allow Notre Dame to exploit defenses that are too focused on stopping the run. However, unlike Ohio State, Notre Dame will not have the same level of receiving talent, which may limit their ability to match the Buckeyes’ explosiveness on offense. Still, Notre Dame’s approach may offer more sustainability over the course of a game, as it is built on physicality and time of possession.
2. Defense: Ohio State’s Talent vs. Notre Dame’s Discipline
Both Ohio State and Notre Dame feature defenses that are capable of shutting down the opposition, but they approach defense in different ways.
Ohio State’s defense, under defensive coordinator Jim Knowles, has made significant strides in recent years. The Buckeyes are known for their elite talent at all levels of the defense, from the defensive line to the secondary. Ohio State’s defensive line, in particular, is consistently one of the most disruptive units in college football, capable of pressuring the quarterback and shutting down the run. If the Buckeyes’ defense can continue to improve in areas such as tackling consistency and pass coverage, they will be a formidable force in the CFP race.
The secondary, which has at times been a weakness in recent years, has made strides toward becoming a more cohesive unit. If Ohio State’s defensive backs can rise to the challenge in 2025, they will become a critical factor in helping the Buckeyes contend for the national championship. The Buckeyes will need to ensure that their defense is able to step up when it matters most, as their offense will likely continue to produce points at a high clip.
Meanwhile, Notre Dame’s defense is built on discipline, toughness, and sound fundamentals. The Fighting Irish’s defensive coordinator, Al Golden, has emphasized a system that is built on maintaining gap integrity and preventing big plays. Notre Dame’s defense is known for being well-coached and fundamentally sound, and it thrives on forcing mistakes and taking advantage of opponents who make errors. While the Irish may not have the same level of raw talent across the board as Ohio State, their ability to limit explosive plays and force turnovers can be just as effective, especially in high-pressure situations.
Notre Dame’s linebackers are often among the best in the country, with playmakers who can disrupt both the running and passing game. If Notre Dame’s defense can generate pressure on opposing quarterbacks and keep Ohio State’s high-flying offense in check, the Irish will have a strong chance of competing in a national title game.
3. Coaching: Ryan Day vs. Marcus Freeman
The coaching battle between Ryan Day of Ohio State and Marcus Freeman of Notre Dame could be one of the most intriguing aspects of a potential national championship matchup. Ryan Day has proven himself to be one of the top offensive minds in college football, consistently fielding high-scoring teams that have the ability to go toe-to-toe with anyone in the country. Under his leadership, Ohio State has become a perennial CFP contender, and his ability to recruit and develop talent is second to none.
However, Day has faced criticism in recent years for not winning a national championship despite having some of the most talented rosters in college football. Ohio State has fallen short in key playoff games, often against SEC opponents, and this has created questions about whether Day can get over the hump and lead the Buckeyes to a title.
Marcus Freeman, meanwhile, is still in the early stages of his head coaching career, but his leadership and energy have already paid dividends for Notre Dame. Freeman has a clear vision for the program and has worked to instill a winning culture that emphasizes toughness, discipline, and accountability. Although Freeman has yet to lead Notre Dame to a national championship, his coaching ability and ability to recruit top-tier talent are evident.
If Freeman can continue to develop as a game-day strategist, Notre Dame will have a great shot at contending for a national title. While Freeman may lack the experience of Day, his passion for the program and his ability to motivate players could be an advantage in high-pressure games.
4. Intangibles: Ohio State’s Pressure vs. Notre Dame’s Legacy
Both Ohio State and Notre Dame bring significant intangibles to the table in a national championship race. Ohio State’s immense pressure to win a title has been well-documented. As one of the most successful programs in college football history, the Buckeyes are expected to compete for championships every season. However, that pressure can sometimes work against them, as the weight of expectations can lead to mistakes or a lack of execution in critical moments.
Notre Dame, on the other hand, has a legacy of success and a passionate fanbase that will support the team no matter what. While the Fighting Irish have not won a national championship in the CFP era, their history is filled with iconic teams and legendary players. This storied tradition can be a motivating factor, driving the players and coaching staff to perform at their best.
