Indiana Men’s Soccer Alumnus Mason Toye Signs with Sporting KC
Mason Toye, a former standout player for the Indiana Hoosiers men’s soccer team, has made waves once again in the soccer world by signing with Major League Soccer (MLS) club Sporting Kansas City. This development marks a significant milestone in Toye’s professional career, as he takes the next step toward solidifying his place as a force in the American soccer scene.
A Rising Star at Indiana
Toye’s path to becoming an MLS player started in the college ranks at Indiana University, where his talent and work ethic quickly gained recognition. A product of the Hoosiers’ celebrated soccer program, Toye spent two seasons (2016–2017) in Bloomington, where he earned a reputation as one of the top attacking players in college soccer. Known for his athleticism, technical skills, and ability to score goals, Toye’s contributions helped elevate the Hoosiers’ offense during his time with the team.
In his freshman year, Toye immediately made an impact, appearing in 22 matches and contributing significantly to the team’s success. His combination of speed, vision, and finishing ability caught the attention of scouts, and he was recognized as one of the top young players in the country. By his sophomore season, Toye was considered a potential future star, capable of taking his game to the next level in MLS.
Throughout his tenure at Indiana, Toye developed his game under the tutelage of head coach Todd Yeagley. The Hoosiers’ program, which has produced numerous MLS players over the years, was the perfect environment for Toye to hone his skills. He played in 40 games over two seasons, scoring 19 goals and providing 9 assists. His ability to create chances and find the back of the net made him a key player for Indiana, as the team contended for national titles.
Toye’s accomplishments did not go unnoticed, and after two successful seasons at Indiana, he made the decision to forgo his remaining college eligibility and enter the 2018 MLS SuperDraft.
The MLS Journey Begins
In January 2018, Mason Toye’s dream of playing in MLS became a reality when he was selected 7th overall in the first round of the MLS SuperDraft by the Montreal Impact (now CF Montreal). The selection was a testament to his immense potential and the hard work he put into his game during his time at Indiana.
Toye’s transition to the professional ranks was not without its challenges, but his time with Montreal provided him with invaluable experience. Over the course of three seasons with the Impact, Toye showed flashes of brilliance while continuing to develop his game. His speed and strength made him a constant threat in the attacking third, and he often played as a central forward, though he was also deployed in other attacking roles. Toye quickly adapted to the physicality and pace of MLS, earning a reputation as a dynamic and versatile forward.
Throughout his tenure with Montreal, Toye accumulated 9 goals and 7 assists across all competitions. His performances were particularly notable in 2020, when he emerged as one of the team’s most consistent attacking players. Despite the challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic and the unique circumstances of the season, Toye’s resilience and determination to succeed stood out. His performances earned praise from fans and coaches alike, with many seeing him as a player with significant upside.
The Move to Sporting Kansas City
After several years with Montreal, Toye’s career took another important turn in 2025 when he signed with Sporting Kansas City. The move represents a fresh start for the 24-year-old forward, who is eager to take his game to new heights with one of MLS’s premier clubs. Sporting Kansas City, known for its strong roster and consistent performance, offers Toye a platform to showcase his abilities and further develop as a player.
Sporting Kansas City is a club with a rich history in MLS, having won multiple championships and consistently competing at a high level. Under the guidance of head coach Peter Vermes, Sporting KC has established a reputation for its disciplined approach to the game and its focus on developing talented players. This philosophy aligns well with Toye’s ambitions, as he seeks to continue his growth and make a more significant impact in MLS.
Toye’s arrival in Kansas City is expected to provide an immediate boost to the team’s offensive capabilities. Sporting KC has been known for its attacking style, and Toye’s pace and goal-scoring ability make him a natural fit for the club’s system. Sporting KC has a history of utilizing dynamic forwards who can stretch defenses, and Toye’s speed and technical abilities should allow him to thrive in the team’s system.
In addition to his individual talents, Toye brings with him a wealth of experience gained from his time in Montreal. His experience playing in MLS, as well as his time competing at a high level in college soccer, will be valuable assets as he adjusts to his new surroundings. The move to Sporting Kansas City gives Toye the opportunity to compete for trophies while continuing to evolve as a player.
What Toye Brings to Sporting Kansas City
Toye’s addition to Sporting Kansas City is a significant one, as it brings a player with both raw potential and the experience of playing at the highest level in North America. One of Toye’s most notable strengths is his ability to stretch the field with his speed. His pace allows him to get in behind defenses, making him a constant threat on counterattacks. He also possesses a keen eye for goal, and his finishing ability has improved throughout his professional career.
In addition to his goal-scoring prowess, Toye is also a versatile forward who can play in multiple attacking roles. His ability to operate as a central striker or in wider positions adds flexibility to Sporting KC’s attacking options. His hold-up play and vision allow him to link up well with his teammates, making him a valuable asset in possession-based systems. His development as a player has been marked by improvements in his decision-making and his ability to contribute to build-up play, which makes him a well-rounded forward.
Another key aspect of Toye’s game is his work ethic. Throughout his career, he has earned a reputation as a player who is committed to his development, constantly working on his fitness and technical skills. This drive and determination have been essential to his success, and they will serve him well as he joins Sporting Kansas City. Toye’s competitive mindset and his desire to improve should help him make a smooth transition to his new team and continue to elevate his game.
Looking Ahead: A Promising Future for Mason Toye
The signing of Mason Toye by Sporting Kansas City is a promising development for both the player and the club. For Toye, the move offers a fresh start and an opportunity to further establish himself as one of the top forwards in MLS. As he continues to refine his game, there is little doubt that Toye has the potential to become one of the league’s most exciting players.
For Sporting Kansas City, Toye’s signing adds depth and talent to an already strong squad. With his pace, versatility, and goal-scoring ability, Toye is poised to make an immediate impact and contribute to the team’s success in the coming seasons. The club’s championship aspirations will benefit from Toye’s dynamic presence in attack, and his arrival could help propel Sporting KC back to the top of the MLS standings.
As Mason Toye embarks on this new chapter of his career, his story serves as a testament to the development opportunities provided by both college soccer and MLS. From his time at Indiana University to his journey through Montreal and now Sporting Kansas City, Toye has demonstrated the power of perseverance, hard work, and dedication. With his continued growth and potential, Toye’s future in MLS looks bright, and he is poised to become one of the league’s most impactful players in the years to come.
In conclusion, Mason Toye’s signing with Sporting Kansas City is a pivotal moment in his career. As he joins one of the top clubs in MLS, he brings with him a wealth of experience and an abundance of talent that will only continue to develop. Fans of Sporting KC can look forward to watching Toye make his mark in Kansas City, while Toye himself has the opportunity to achieve new heights in his professional soccer journey.
