The College Football Playoff (CFP) National Championship is the pinnacle of college football, and every year, teams from across the country battle their way through grueling regular seasons and intense bowl games to earn a spot in the final matchup. With a rich history of football excellence, both Ohio State University and the University of Notre Dame have consistently been two of the most storied programs in college football. As of January 2025, both teams have found themselves in the conversation for national supremacy. The question of whether Ohio State or Notre Dame will prevail in the CFP National Championship is a compelling one, involving a deep dive into each team’s strengths, weaknesses, recent performances, and overall trajectory toward the title.
Ohio State: A Powerhouse of Talent and Tradition
Ohio State has long been one of the most successful programs in college football. Under head coach Ryan Day, the Buckeyes have established themselves as consistent playoff contenders, regularly competing for Big Ten titles and national championships. The 2024-2025 season has been no different, with Ohio State entering the playoff as one of the top teams in the nation.
Offense: Dynamic and Versatile
One of the hallmarks of Ohio State’s success over the past several seasons has been its high-powered offense. The Buckeyes boast a wealth of talent, particularly at the quarterback and wide receiver positions. Quarterback Kyle McCord, a dynamic signal-caller with a strong arm and great mobility, has emerged as one of the nation’s best. His ability to make plays both in and out of the pocket makes Ohio State’s offense particularly dangerous.
The Buckeyes are also known for their depth at wide receiver. Players like Marvin Harrison Jr., a potential first-round NFL draft pick, and Emeka Egbuka, one of the most consistent and dangerous pass-catchers in the nation, provide McCord with an elite group of targets. Ohio State’s receiving corps is one of the deepest in college football, making it difficult for opposing defenses to key in on any one player. This group’s ability to stretch the field and make big plays at any moment is a key advantage for Ohio State.
In the running game, Ohio State has consistently been able to move the ball with authority. Running backs like TreVeyon Henderson and Miyan Williams bring a combination of power and speed, creating a balanced offensive attack that keeps defenses on their toes. The offensive line has been strong, paving the way for these backs to find daylight while also protecting McCord in the pocket.
Defense: Tough and Tenacious
Ohio State’s defense has been another point of pride in recent years. While the Buckeyes’ defense was once a question mark under previous coaches, they have since evolved into one of the most dominant defensive units in the nation. Defensive coordinator Jim Knowles has implemented a system that focuses on speed, aggressiveness, and versatility, all of which have contributed to Ohio State’s success on that side of the ball.
The defensive line is a major strength, with players like J.T. Tuimoloau and Jack Sawyer providing pressure on opposing quarterbacks. These edge rushers, coupled with the interior presence of Tyleik Williams, make it difficult for any offense to get into a rhythm. Ohio State’s ability to disrupt the opposing quarterback can lead to turnovers and stalled drives, which gives their offense even more opportunities to score.
The linebackers are fast and physical, with standout players like Steele Chambers and Cody Simon roaming the field and making plays. They have the ability to stop the run and cover in pass defense, making them one of the most well-rounded linebacker corps in college football.
In the secondary, Ohio State has a wealth of talent as well. Players like Denzel Burke and Jordan Hancock provide lockdown coverage in the passing game, while safety Sonny Styles has the ability to make plays both in coverage and against the run. The Buckeyes’ secondary is adept at preventing big plays, which is crucial in big games like the CFP National Championship.
Special Teams: A Reliable Unit
Special teams often play a pivotal role in close games, and Ohio State has a solid group in this area. Kicker Noah Ruggles has been a reliable weapon for the Buckeyes, and punter Jesse Mirco provides a strong leg that helps flip the field. Ohio State’s return game, led by playmakers like Egbuka and Henderson, also adds an extra dimension to their special teams unit, capable of changing the momentum of a game in an instant.
Coaching and Culture: Championship Pedigree
Ryan Day has proven himself as one of the top coaches in college football. His ability to recruit elite talent, develop players, and consistently contend for championships is a testament to his coaching acumen. Day has also shown a knack for making in-game adjustments and keeping his team composed under pressure.
Ohio State’s championship pedigree is undeniable. With eight national championships and a long history of success, the Buckeyes know what it takes to win on the big stage. This culture of excellence is ingrained in the program and gives Ohio State a distinct advantage in high-pressure situations.
Notre Dame: A Tradition of Excellence
Notre Dame has long been one of the most prestigious programs in college football. With a rich history dating back to the early 20th century, the Fighting Irish are synonymous with college football greatness. Under head coach Marcus Freeman, Notre Dame has taken a step forward, positioning itself as a legitimate national title contender in 2025.
Offense: Methodical and Efficient
Notre Dame’s offense has evolved into a more balanced, methodical attack under Freeman’s leadership. Quarterback Sam Hartman, a transfer from Wake Forest, has brought stability to the position. Hartman’s experience, poise, and ability to make quick decisions have been crucial for the Fighting Irish’s success. His ability to read defenses and make smart throws allows the offense to stay on schedule and maintain control of the game.
Running back Audric Estime has been a workhorse for Notre Dame, providing both power and speed in the running game. Estime’s ability to break tackles and pick up yards after contact makes him a constant threat, especially in short-yardage situations. Notre Dame’s offensive line is one of the best in the country, paving the way for Estime and giving Hartman the time he needs to make plays in the passing game.
While Notre Dame may not have the same high-flying passing attack as Ohio State, their offense is efficient and capable of controlling the tempo of the game. The Fighting Irish are excellent at managing the clock and limiting mistakes, which can be a huge asset in a high-stakes playoff game.
Defense: Physical and Disciplined
Notre Dame’s defense is one of the best in the nation, and it is anchored by a physical, disciplined unit that can go toe-to-toe with anyone. Defensive coordinator Al Golden has implemented a system that emphasizes sound fundamentals and aggressive play, which has paid off in spades for the Irish.
The defensive line is stout, with players like Jayson Ademilola and Howard Cross clogging up running lanes and getting after the quarterback. Notre Dame’s ability to pressure the quarterback and stop the run has been a defining feature of their defense throughout the season.
The linebacking corps is another area where Notre Dame excels. With players like Jack Kiser and Marist Liufau, the Irish have a fast and versatile group that can cover ground quickly. They are equally capable of stuffing the run and covering tight ends and running backs in the passing game.
In the secondary, Notre Dame has strong playmakers, including safety Xavier Watts and cornerback Benjamin Morrison. These players are capable of making game-changing plays in the passing game, whether it’s breaking up passes or forcing turnovers.
Special Teams: Steady and Reliable
Like Ohio State, Notre Dame has a strong special teams unit. Kicker Blake Grupe has been reliable for the Irish, while punter Jon Sot provides excellent field position. Notre Dame’s return game is also a threat, as the team has several playmakers who can make big returns and swing momentum in their favor.
Coaching and Culture: Resilient and Consistent
Marcus Freeman has quickly established himself as one of the rising stars in college football. After taking over as head coach in 2022, Freeman has instilled a culture of resilience and discipline that has helped elevate Notre Dame to a new level of competitiveness. His ability to manage the game and keep his team focused in high-pressure moments is a significant asset.
Notre Dame’s rich tradition and history of success provide the Fighting Irish with a strong foundation. While they may not have the same number of national championships as Ohio State, Notre Dame’s pedigree and pride in their program have carried them to great heights. The Fighting Irish have a strong belief in their ability to compete on the national stage, and that confidence can make a difference in a close game.
The Matchup: Ohio State vs. Notre Dame
Both Ohio State and Notre Dame bring different styles to the table, making this potential CFP National Championship matchup a fascinating one.
Offensive Firepower vs. Defensive Strength
Ohio State’s offense, led by McCord and a bevy of playmakers, will look to exploit Notre Dame’s defense, which has been strong but will face its toughest test of the season. The Buckeyes have the ability to put up points quickly, and their passing attack will be a major challenge for Notre Dame’s secondary. If Ohio State can establish its passing game early and stretch the field, it could force Notre Dame to adjust and open up running lanes for their backs.
On the other hand, Notre Dame’s methodical offense will look to control the clock and limit Ohio State’s offensive opportunities. Hartman’s ability to manage the game and make quick, efficient throws will be crucial in keeping Ohio State’s defense on its heels. The Fighting Irish will likely try to establish the run with Estime and wear down Ohio State’s defense over the course of the game.
Turnovers and Special Teams
In a game of this magnitude, turnovers and special teams can often be the difference. Ohio State’s ability to generate pressure on the quarterback could lead to mistakes from Hartman, while Notre Dame’s discipline and solid fundamentals on special teams could prevent big plays from the Buckeyes’ return game. Both teams have the ability to make game-changing plays in these areas, and whichever team can capitalize on turnovers and field position will likely have the upper hand.
Key Factors for Success
For Ohio State to prevail, McCord will need to make quick decisions and avoid forcing throws into tight coverage. The offensive line must protect him from Notre Dame’s pass rush, and the running game must be efficient to keep the Irish’s defense honest. On defense, Ohio State’s pass rush will be critical in pressuring Hartman and forcing him into mistakes.
For Notre Dame to win, Hartman must manage the game and make the most of his opportunities when they arise. The Fighting Irish will need to keep Ohio State’s offense off the field by controlling the clock with their running game. On defense, they must remain disciplined and limit big plays while forcing Ohio State into third-and-long situations.
