SEC Quarterback Rankings: Where Does John Mateer Fit In With Arch Manning & Co. in 2025?
The Southeastern Conference (SEC) is widely regarded as one of the most competitive and prestigious football conferences in the country, and it’s home to some of the best quarterbacks in the nation. From Heisman Trophy winners to future NFL stars, the SEC has produced its fair share of elite signal-callers. As the 2025 college football season approaches, the race to determine the top quarterbacks in the SEC is heating up, with a new crop of talent coming in, including highly touted freshmen and emerging stars ready to take center stage.
One of the most intriguing names in the 2025 SEC quarterback landscape is John Mateer, a talented and promising young quarterback who will likely be competing for a spot at one of the top programs in the conference. Mateer’s arrival in the SEC is anticipated with great excitement, especially as he navigates the competition alongside other high-profile quarterbacks like Arch Manning, Jalen Milroe, and Carson Beck. With the influx of talent across the SEC, there is no shortage of questions surrounding Mateer’s position and where he will fall in the rankings of SEC quarterbacks for the 2025 season.
In this article, we’ll explore John Mateer’s background, his playing style, how he compares to other quarterbacks in the SEC, and where he might land in the rankings as the 2025 season progresses. We’ll also break down the competition he’ll face, particularly from players like Arch Manning, who enters college with immense expectations, and others who are expected to be key figures in the conference.
John Mateer: The Up-and-Coming Quarterback
Before diving into the SEC quarterback landscape, it’s important to understand who John Mateer is and what makes him such a highly anticipated prospect. Mateer comes from Lakewood, Colorado, where he had an outstanding high school career, consistently earning accolades and recognition as one of the top quarterbacks in his class. As a dual-threat quarterback, Mateer brings a combination of strong arm strength, impressive accuracy, and the ability to extend plays with his legs.
Mateer’s high school career was marked by his poise in the pocket and his ability to lead his team to victory in high-pressure situations. His passing numbers were consistently high, showcasing his ability to make all the throws necessary for success at the next level. His leadership qualities, coupled with his work ethic and competitive drive, have made him one of the most intriguing quarterbacks in the 2025 class.
While many quarterbacks entering the SEC have the ability to dominate through the air, Mateer’s dual-threat ability allows him to create chaos for opposing defenses both through the air and on the ground. His ability to keep defenses on their toes and punish them with his legs adds an extra dimension to his game, making him a versatile weapon in an increasingly dynamic quarterback landscape.
Mateer has already begun making waves in recruiting circles, with top programs across the country expressing interest in his services. His skill set has caught the attention of major SEC programs, where he is seen as a potential future star.
The SEC Quarterback Landscape in 2025
The SEC has long been known for its ability to develop elite quarterbacks, and the 2025 season is no different. As teams gear up for the upcoming season, several standout quarterbacks are expected to lead their respective programs to new heights. The competition will be fierce, with some of the most high-profile signal-callers in college football set to battle it out for supremacy.
Let’s take a look at some of the quarterbacks that will define the SEC in 2025 and how they compare to John Mateer.
Arch Manning: The Freshman Phenomenon
One of the most highly anticipated quarterbacks in recent memory, Arch Manning enters the SEC with immense expectations. The nephew of Peyton and Eli Manning, Arch comes from a football family with a legacy of success, and he is expected to be a game-changer for whichever program he chooses.
Manning has chosen to play for Texas, which will make its SEC debut in 2025. His decision to take his talents to Austin has raised the stakes in the SEC quarterback race, especially as his family pedigree and immense natural talent make him a potential Heisman contender from day one. Arch Manning is known for his precision passing, calm demeanor in the pocket, and impressive football IQ. While Manning is not a dual-threat quarterback in the traditional sense, his ability to read defenses and make accurate throws is among the best in his class.
Manning is likely to be a starter from the get-go, and his place in the SEC quarterback rankings will depend heavily on how quickly he adjusts to the faster pace and competition of the SEC. Given his pedigree and potential, Manning is undoubtedly a top-tier talent to watch in 2025.
Jalen Milroe: Alabama’s Dynamic Quarterback
Another prominent name in the SEC quarterback conversation is Jalen Milroe, who enters his junior season with the Alabama Crimson Tide in 2025. Milroe has already shown flashes of brilliance during his time as the backup to Bryce Young, and with Young heading to the NFL, Milroe is expected to take over as Alabama’s starting quarterback.
Milroe is known for his incredible athleticism, strong arm, and ability to make plays with his legs. A true dual-threat quarterback, Milroe has the potential to be a game-changer for the Crimson Tide. His ability to create big plays in both the passing and running game will make him a key player in Alabama’s offensive scheme under head coach Nick Saban.
If Milroe can develop his passing consistency, he has the tools to be one of the top quarterbacks in the SEC in 2025. His dual-threat ability, combined with Alabama’s powerful offensive line and skill players, could make Milroe a Heisman candidate and one of the top quarterbacks in the nation.
Carson Beck: Georgia’s Steady Hand
Another SEC quarterback to keep an eye on is Carson Beck, who is expected to be the starter for the Georgia Bulldogs in 2025. Beck has patiently waited for his opportunity behind former star quarterback Stetson Bennett, but with Bennett off to the NFL, Beck is primed to take the reins of the reigning national champions.
Beck’s calm demeanor and ability to make all the necessary throws make him a dangerous quarterback in the SEC. While Beck may not have the same dual-threat ability as some of the other quarterbacks in the conference, his accuracy, decision-making, and leadership will be key to Georgia’s success in 2025. Beck has the potential to be a top-tier quarterback in the SEC and could help lead Georgia to another national championship under head coach Kirby Smart.
John Mateer: A Rising Star in the SEC
Given the talent already present in the SEC in 2025, where does John Mateer fit in? As a highly touted recruit with a dual-threat skill set, Mateer has the potential to make an immediate impact in the SEC, especially with a program that values versatility at the quarterback position. However, in a conference full of established quarterbacks like Manning, Milroe, and Beck, Mateer may have to bide his time before he can claim a starting spot.
Mateer’s advantage, however, is his ability to develop quickly. His dual-threat abilities and impressive physicality make him a unique talent, and his potential to develop into a top quarterback in the SEC will depend on the system and coaching staff he joins. If Mateer can refine his passing game and continue to work on his consistency, he could become one of the top quarterbacks in the SEC within the next few years.
Where Does Mateer Rank Among SEC Quarterbacks in 2025?
It’s still too early to definitively place John Mateer among the top quarterbacks in the SEC for 2025, as much depends on his development, the program he plays for, and his ability to compete with the aforementioned quarterbacks. However, based on his skill set, Mateer could quickly rise up the rankings as a top-tier dual-threat quarterback, especially if he lands with a program that maximizes his potential.
In 2025, it’s likely that Arch Manning and Jalen Milroe will be among the top quarterbacks in the SEC, given their respective pedigrees and skill sets. Carson Beck will also be in the conversation as one of the steady and reliable quarterbacks leading a championship contender. Mateer, though not as well-known yet as some of these quarterbacks, could be an exciting new name in the SEC if he continues to develop and prove himself on the field.
In conclusion, while it’s difficult to predict exactly where John Mateer will fit into the SEC quarterback rankings in 2025, his talent and dual-threat ability suggest that he will be a force to be reckoned with in the coming years. The SEC is home to some of the best quarterbacks in the country, and if Mateer can rise to the occasion, he could join the ranks of these elite signal-callers and make a name for himself as one of the top quarterbacks in the conference.
