College Football’s Top 2025 QBs: Where Does Texas Longhorns’ Arch Manning Rank?
The college football landscape is constantly evolving, and one of the most exciting areas to watch is the quarterback position. The 2025 season promises to be a pivotal year for some of the nation’s top quarterbacks, including a certain highly-touted recruit who has already made waves before even stepping onto the field for a full season: Arch Manning, the Texas Longhorns’ prized freshman quarterback.
Manning, the grandson of NFL legend Archie Manning and nephew of Super Bowl MVPs Peyton and Eli Manning, comes to Texas with one of the most famous football legacies in history. But the pressure and expectations surrounding him are immense, not only because of his family name but also because of the immense potential he showed as a high school phenom. As college football fans eagerly await the debut of this highly anticipated recruit, the question arises: Where does Arch Manning rank among the top quarterbacks in the 2025 class, and how does his potential stack up against other rising stars in the college football world?
In this article, we will explore Arch Manning’s recruitment, evaluate his strengths and weaknesses as a prospect, and compare him to other quarterbacks in the 2025 class to determine where he fits among the elite QBs in college football.
The Arch Manning Legacy: A Football Dynasty
Arch Manning might be the most well-known name in high school football right now, and for good reason. Born into the iconic Manning family, Arch is the son of Cooper Manning and the grandson of Archie Manning, both of whom played a role in shaping the family’s football legacy. His uncles, Peyton Manning and Eli Manning, are two of the most successful quarterbacks in NFL history, with Peyton regarded as one of the greatest to ever play the game.
Despite being in such a high-profile family, Arch Manning managed to carve out his own identity in high school. Attending Isidore Newman School in New Orleans, Manning was a standout quarterback from an early age, setting numerous records and leading his team to significant victories throughout his high school career. His performance on the field made him a five-star prospect, and his recruitment quickly turned into one of the most publicized in recent history.
His decision to commit to the Texas Longhorns in June 2023 only added to the national intrigue surrounding his career. Steve Sarkisian, Texas’s head coach, has proven to be one of the best quarterbacks coaches in college football, and his system seemed like the perfect fit for Manning’s skill set. But with the tremendous expectations that accompany Manning’s name, the question arises: How does he stack up against other top quarterbacks in the 2025 class?
Arch Manning’s Strengths as a Quarterback
As Arch Manning prepares to take the field for the Texas Longhorns in the 2025 season, there is much to like about his game. Here are some of the key strengths that make Manning a top-tier prospect and one of the most anticipated players in college football.
1. Elite Arm Talent
One of the most striking aspects of Manning’s game is his arm talent. He has a cannon for an arm, capable of making all the throws that are required at the college level. From deep throws down the sideline to precise laser throws in the middle of the field, Manning has the arm strength to challenge defenses from all areas of the field. His ability to make throws on the run is also impressive, as he can effortlessly generate velocity while keeping his body balanced.
Manning’s arm strength allows him to stretch the defense vertically, opening up opportunities for the offense to exploit both the intermediate and deep portions of the field. This is a key feature of the Texas offense under Steve Sarkisian, who often relies on a dynamic passing attack. Manning’s ability to push the ball downfield is a crucial element of his game that will allow him to thrive in Austin.
2. Poise and Composure
Despite the immense pressure surrounding his recruitment and family legacy, Manning has shown a remarkable ability to stay composed. On the field, he exudes confidence and doesn’t get rattled by adverse situations. Whether his team is down by multiple scores or facing a high-pressure situation late in a game, Manning keeps his cool, makes his reads, and delivers the football with poise.
This composure is particularly important for a freshman quarterback entering a high-profile program like Texas, where the expectations are sky-high. Manning’s ability to handle adversity and maintain focus will be critical as he navigates the spotlight at the college level.
3. Football IQ and Decision-Making
Manning has an advanced understanding of the game for his age. He has a natural feel for the pocket, and his ability to read defenses and make quick decisions is impressive. Manning processes information at an elite level, and he’s shown the ability to go through his progressions quickly and accurately. This football IQ, combined with his arm strength, makes him an ideal fit for the up-tempo, pass-heavy offense at Texas.
One of the key areas of development for any young quarterback is making good decisions under pressure. Manning’s decision-making is already well above average for a player of his age, and that should only improve as he gains more experience.
4. Athleticism and Mobility
Although Manning is primarily known for his arm talent and mental game, he also has the ability to make plays with his legs. While he’s not a dual-threat quarterback in the mold of Lamar Jackson or Kyler Murray, Manning is athletic enough to extend plays and gain yardage when the pocket breaks down. He’s quick enough to avoid pressure and can make some plays in the open field when necessary.
While Manning won’t be running the football as much as some of the more mobile quarterbacks in the 2025 class, his athleticism is a nice added element to his game. It helps keep defenses on their toes and provides him with an extra level of playmaking ability.
Where Does Arch Manning Rank Among the 2025 Quarterbacks?
As we look ahead to the 2025 season, the quarterback position is filled with tremendous talent, and Arch Manning will have some stiff competition as he looks to make his mark on college football. But based on his skill set and the expectations surrounding his recruitment, Manning should be considered one of the top quarterbacks in the country.
In the 2025 class, some of the names that will likely challenge Manning for the title of best quarterback include:
- Jaden Rashada (Florida Gators)
- Malachi Nelson (USC Trojans)
- Dante Moore (UCLA Bruins)
- Jackson Arnold (Oklahoma Sooners)
These quarterbacks have all shown incredible talent during their high school careers and have the potential to be impact players in college football. Jaden Rashada, in particular, had a spectacular senior season at Pittsburg High School and should be a player to watch in the SEC. Malachi Nelson, a USC commit, has received glowing reviews for his ability to lead an offense and his strong connection with Coach Lincoln Riley. Dante Moore is another highly-rated prospect who’s set to join UCLA, and he has all the tools to be a future star in the Pac-12. Jackson Arnold is a Sooner and one of the top quarterbacks in the country, with a well-rounded game that should translate well at the collegiate level.
However, when comparing Manning to these quarterbacks, it’s clear that he has the pedigree, tools, and intangibles to compete for the top spot. Manning is arguably one of the most polished quarterbacks in the 2025 class, with the ideal blend of arm strength, accuracy, football IQ, and mental toughness that coaches covet. He’s a natural leader, and his ability to stay calm in pressure situations makes him a special talent.
Moreover, Texas offers Manning a high-profile platform to shine. Under Steve Sarkisian’s guidance, Manning will have the opportunity to develop within an offensive system that has produced elite quarterbacks in the past. With weapons around him in the Longhorns’ offense and a strong supporting cast, Manning is poised to step in and make an immediate impact.
What Does the Future Hold for Arch Manning?
As Manning enters his first season with Texas in 2025, the stakes are incredibly high. The Longhorns are looking to return to prominence, and Manning’s development will be key to their success. The hope is that he can live up to the hype and deliver on the potential he has shown since high school.
There’s no denying that Arch Manning is one of the most talented quarterbacks in the 2025 class and one of the most anticipated college football players in recent memory. Whether he ultimately emerges as the best quarterback in the country remains to be seen, but his potential is undeniable. With his combination of skill, pedigree, and mental toughness, Manning has everything he needs to succeed at the highest level of college football.
As Texas looks to return to national championship contention, Arch Manning will be a central figure in their quest for greatness. Fans and analysts alike will be closely watching to see how this future star develops and how his journey unfolds on the grand stage of college football.
Leave a Reply